Movies for Guys movie reviews



      Home

      Reviews
          Action
          Comedy
          Drama
          Horror
          Music
          Sci-Fi
          Thriller
          Western
          Full Listing

      News / Blog

      Credits

      Articles










Gladiator
Rated R
Runtime: 2hr 45min
Starring: Russell Crowe, Joaquin Phoenix, Connie Nielsen, Oliver Reed

MFG Rating: 3/5

DVD Features

Video: Widescreen enhanced and the picture quality overall is very good. This movie is so huge there are several distinctly different types of photography ranging from dark and murky to extremely bright. Some were reproduced better than others on DVD, but the overall picture quality is very pleasing.

Audio: You have your choice of Dolby Digital 5.1 and DTS 6.1. Yes, I said 6.1, this is only the second DVD out to use it if you happen to have the hardware to support it. It'll work just fine on regular DTS equipment as well. And in fact, the DTS track even without the back center channel sounds excellent. The DD 5.1 track is also solid, but you'll notice the difference if you have high end equipment due to the powerful Hans Zimmer score which benefits from the higher bit rate of DTS.

Extras: This is a 2 disc set, so it's loaded. You get an HBO "First Look", a look at the real gladiators and their history from the Discovery Channel, production notes, commentary, lots of deleted scenes and unused footage, interviews, a production diary kept by the kid who plays Lucius, concept art, storyboards, and a photo gallery.

Add this DVD to your collection

Movies For Guys' Original Review of the Theatrical Release

Gladiator is Ridley Scott's attempt at an epic in the same vein as Braveheart. He succeeds in creating an epic at least. It's a bladder buster at nearly 3 hours and moves at a pace only slightly better than an insurance seminar.

gladiatorSet during the peak of the Roman Empire, the story revolves around Maximus, one of the best General's in Emperor Marcus Aurelias' army. The emperor is dying and makes his wishes known that Maximus be his successor instead of his son Commodus. As you might expect, going through life with a name like Commodus, and then being passed over by his own father doesn't sit well with the Caesar's son. He orders the death of Maximus, who manages to escape and become a gladiator while hiding his identity. He will attempt to return to Rome to ultimately seek his revenge.

Lots of people have predicted this to be the movie that makes Russell Crowe a mega-star as he stars here as Maximus, our Gladiaor. I'm not sure that's going to happen. His performance is fine, but this is a bit of a tough movie to watch. The movie opens with a battle scene that had me thinking this flick was going to absolutely rock. But even before the scene was over, Ridley Scott started mucking with the picture. During the climax of the battle he dropped the frame rate and suddenly it's like we're watching the movie in Real Video or something. Whether this was done for artistic effect or perhaps to hide a problem such as cheap special effects, it was annoyingl and really hurt my enjoyment of the film.

The mainstream critics so far seem to really like this movie and many people are predicting it is going to do really big business. It barely gets 3 stars on our scale, and I have no desire to see it again at least until it hits DVD. I have two big problems with the movie, the first is that this movie is dark in every regard. It's even shot so that every scene looks overcast and gloomy. Combine that with the length of the movie, a terribly slow pace, effects that are downright cheesy, and summer blockbusters just around the corner, and I do not see this doing quite the level of business many are predicting.

-Billy Bob

Talk about this movie!

Vital Stats
                   
Less
More

Gun Play
                   
Pre-dates guns, but does a catapult count?


Blood & Gore
                   
Not as explicit as I would've expected, but still has the blood flying.


Car Chases
                   
You'll have to settle for chariots...

T&A
                   
Nary a nipple in sight!


Chuckles
                   
I dont remember a single chuckle, this thing is dark.